audioMIDI.com
audioMIDI.com  
Search
   Your WishlistLogoutAdvanced Search  Advanced Search   
Nice2Know aM-U Podcasts Seminars Videos Reviews About Us Home Your Account Your Cart
  Sales: (866)-283-4601
  (818) 993-0772
  Online Contact Form
  
Expand List
Specials
B-Stocks and Blowouts
Academic Sales
Accessories
Audio Interfaces
Computers
DJ Gear
Guitar Gear
Keyboards
MIDI Gear
Microphones
Outboard Gear
Plug-ins
Podcasting
Recording
Software
Sounds
Studio Furnishings
Training and Tutorials
Virtual Instruments
Shop By Brand
Show All Brands
Ableton
Alesis
Antares
Apogee
Apple
Behringer
Big Fish
Cakewalk
Cycling '74
Digidesign
EastWest
IK Multimedia
Korg
Line 6
MOTU
M-Audio
Native Instruments
Propellerhead
RME
Roland
Spectrasonics
Steinberg
Synthogy
Waves
Yamaha
audioMIDI.com Classroom : Computers and Hardware - How to Buy   FREE Ground Shipping*

.

Which Macintosh Should I Buy (For Music)?

By Kevin P Murphy

A frequent question we receive at audioMIDI.com is "I am thinking about buying a new/used Macintosh. What should I buy?" While it is impossible to account for every person's needs, here are some considerations.

January 15, 2002

 

Current Macintosh Models

If you are buying a new computer, there are basically 4 different options (with several variations of each, mostly dealing with different speed processors, memory, etc.). Starting sometime this year, all new Macintoshes will ship with OS X as their only operating system (currently most ship with both OS9 and OS. This is a huge problem for most Music and Audio users, as most audio programs and hardware are not yet OS X Compatible. Macintosh OS 9.2 is still the best choice for the current models so when looking for a computer, make sure that it has OS 9.2.

Some considerations for all new Mac models

  • If you need to use OMS to connect a USB MIDI device to a Macintosh, most people have more success with using version 2.3.7 rather than 2.3.8.
  • All current models include USB. While USB is great for MIDI, USB is limited in terms of how many audio tracks (2-4 simultaneous tracks) and resolution (24bit 48kHz is about the limit) it can do.

G4 (Tower)

The G4 is the top of the line as far as the Macintosh goes. With 3-5 PCI slots, FireWire, and USB, the G4 gives you the most choices as far as connectivity. This is the computer of choice if you are simultaneously recording multiple tracks of audio with MIDI. The G4 processor is the fastest on the planet (for programs that have been written to take advantage of it, such as Logic Audio).

While you can put 1.5 Gigabytes of RAM in your G4, some programs such as Logic Audio currently have a problem with more than 1 Gig of physical RAM installed.

G4 PowerBook (Titanium)

The G4 PowerBook sports the same processor as the G4 tower, so it has a fast processor, but lacks the PCI slots that allow a wide variety of audio cards. The Titanium does include a PCMCIA slot as well as FireWire, so multiple tracks of audio are possible. If your needs are high-end audio but in a portable package, the G4 PowerBook is the machine for you.

iMac and iBook

The iMac was the largest selling single model of computer ever, and was the first computer to completely do away with things such as serial ports, SCSI, in favor of using only USB. If your audio recording needs are simple, then this Mac will work for you. The current iMac models also include FireWire port. With more and more FireWire devices coming out, multiple tracks of audio recording are possible.

The current iBook (the squareish one) has the same specifications as the current iMac (with notable exceptions being the monitor and the portability).

Don't let your first reaction be that the G3 processor isn't as powerful as the G4. While it is true that the G4 can blow the G3 away in terms of speed, it only is on programs that have been rewritten to take advantage of the G4. Otherwise, a similar speed G3 and G4 will perform about the same.

While the current models include FireWire, the older models do not. If you plan to record more than 2 tracks of audio simultaneously, then you need to make sure that you have the more recent model.

Discontinued Macintosh Models

Just because it is not the latest and greatest, doesn't mean it isn't a good computer for music. Used Macintoshes can be a great bet.While it is impossible to list every different model ever made, many can be grouped together.

G3 (Beige or Blue and White)

The Beige G3 is a great machine for doing music. The G3 processor is nice and speedy and this model has PCI slots for adding audio cards. The G3 will also be available for OS X in the future (pretty much no other models older than a Beige G3, including any computer with a G3 or G4 upgrade card, will be OS X compatible).

A later model G3 was in a blue and white tower. This model has all of the conection features as the above G4 tower, but is based on the G3 processor (and has a slightly different motherboard design). Some people have reported problems with running Firewire while using OS9.1 but OS9.04 seemed to work OK.

G3 PowerBook

Can't afford a G4 Titanium? Check around for a G3 PowerBook. There were several models, with the later ones featuring both USB and PCMCIA for more audio input options.

4 digit Power Macintosh or Performa Models

There were dozens of different models of PowerMac, so I can't go into all of the variations here. Look for the faster 604E chip found in the later model computers rather than the 603 or 601 chips. Many of the tower chassis offer an easy processor upgrade path (I personally am still holding on to my 8500, but it now sports a G3 upgrade card).

61xx, 71xx, 81xx Power Macintosh or Performa

At first glance these might seem to be just slower versions of the older PowerMac computers as above. However, these 3 systems, instead of having PCI slots for adding audio cards, use the older NuBus audio card technology. Currently there are no companies that are still making NuBus cards. Look to buy one of these computers for music only if it includes all of the audio hardware that you need.

If you have an older MIDI program and want to do MIDI sequencing only, these computers do make nice MIDI machines. If your audio needs are VERY simple (like with eartraining programs) then the built in Mic input will also work just fine.

Non-Power Macintosh

As above with the first generation PowerMac's, these computers use NuBus card slots (if they have card slots at all). Some older MIDI programs and notation programs will work OK on these systems, but forget about trying to do audio on these systems. If you need a simple MIDI setup and have access to an older program, then you can probably pick up one of these for just a few dollars.

 

 

 

© 2008 audioMIDI.com. All Rights Reserved.
Publisher does not accept liability for incorrect spelling, printing errors (including prices), incorrect manufacturer's specifications or changes, or grammatical inaccuracies in any product included in the audioMIDI.com Website.
Prices subject to change without notice.